Outreach message analyzer

Paste your LinkedIn invitation note, first message or follow-up: a score out of 100, issues ranked by impact and the fix for each one. Free, no signup, nothing leaves your browser.

Message type
Load an example:
60/ 100Needs a touch-up
271 characters5 sentences2 questions4 I / we · 4 you

What to fix, by impact

Important-12 pts

No specific fact about the person

Nothing in the message proves you looked at their profile or activity. The same text could go to a thousand people, and the prospect can tell.

Fix: Add one sentence on what you saw: a post, a hire, a job change, something in common. “I read your post about onboarding” is enough.

Important-10 pts

A bit long: 5 sentences, 271 characters

Aim for 2 to 4 lines. Every extra sentence pushes your question further down the screen.

Fix: Delete the least useful sentence, which is often the one describing your offer.

Important-10 ptsfixed in the version below

2 questions in the same message

Faced with several questions, the prospect does not know which one to answer, and answering all of them takes effort. They put it off.

Fix: Keep one question, the easiest one, and put it at the end.

Minor-4 ptsfixed in the version below

Overused phrase: “I hope you're doing well”

It shows up in so many outreach messages that it flags a template from the first words, and adds nothing.

Fix: Delete it. It says nothing about the person and pushes the one sentence that matters further down.

Minor-4 ptsfixed in the version below

Overused phrase: “I'm reaching out”

It shows up in so many outreach messages that it flags a template from the first words, and adds nothing.

Fix: State the reason right away: “I read your post about…” instead of “I'm reaching out because…”.

What already works

  • Centered on the prospect: 4 you against 4 I / we.
  • No link, no price, no meeting request.
  • The prospect is addressed by first name.

Cleaned version

Score after cleanup: 88 / 100

Hi Thomas, I help agencies like yours with their LinkedIn prospecting. We have helped several founders structure their follow-ups and save time every week. Is this a topic for you right now?

Only what fixed rules can correct on their own was changed. Read it again before sending: the substance stays yours.

Makelead sends your note, first message and follow-ups for you, within 200 invitations over any rolling 7 days, and stops the sequence as soon as the prospect replies. You write the messages once.

Why check your message before you send it

A LinkedIn outreach message is decided in a few seconds: the prospect sees your name and the first line in the preview, and decides whether to open it. If they do, they look for what you want from them. Most messages that go unanswered are not badly written. They make known mistakes: a calendar link too early, three questions in a row, an opener everyone uses, a text that talks about the sender from start to finish.

This analyzer spots those mistakes with fixed rules, no AI, right in your browser. It gives a score out of 100, ranks the remarks from the most costly to the least serious and gives the fix for each one. When the rules are enough to clean the message, it also shows you the cleaned version. To check a post rather than a private message, use the post checker instead.

How it works

  1. 1Pick the message type: invitation note (200 characters max), first message after they accept, or follow-up. The rules change with the type.
  2. 2Paste your message, or load one of the three examples to see how the tool judges a good, an average and a weak message.
  3. 3Read the remarks in order: the first one costs you the most replies. Edit straight in the box, the score updates as you type.
  4. 4Once the score is above 80, copy the message and send it.

Anatomy of a LinkedIn outreach message that gets a reply

An outreach message is not trying to sell or to book a meeting. Its only goal is to get a reply. Anything that makes that reply harder to write lowers your odds, and anything that makes it obvious raises them. The elements below show up in almost every message that starts a conversation, and their absence explains most of the silence.

The first name and one specific fact, in the first line

The LinkedIn inbox preview shows your name and the start of your message. That line is where the prospect decides whether to open it. “Hello, I hope this message finds you well” looks like the dozens of messages they received the same month, while “Claire, I read your post about onboarding sales reps” can only be meant for her.

The specific fact proves you are not sending the same text to a thousand people. It can come from a post they published, a comment, an open position, a job change or something you genuinely have in common. One sentence is enough, as long as it can be checked. “I saw your profile” proves nothing, while “I saw you are hiring two sales reps in Austin” shows you actually looked.

Talk about them before you talk about yourself

Count the “I” and “we” in your message, then the “you” and “your”. When the first group clearly wins, the message is about you: your company, your offer, your clients. The prospect scans every line for what concerns them, and if they find nothing they close the conversation.

This is not about banning “I”. “I help agencies like yours” is a useful sentence, because it places what you do in relation to them. The problem is the introduction that drags on, with your company history, your list of services and the names of your clients. The analyzer flags the message when references to you clearly outnumber references to the prospect.

One easy question, placed at the end

The question is what turns a message that gets read into a message that gets answered. It should take one line to answer, ideally yes or no with a detail. “Is that something you are dealing with right now?” takes five seconds. “What are your main sales challenges for the year?” asks a stranger for a structured answer, and almost nobody takes that time.

Ask one question only. Two questions in a row force the prospect to choose, and the most common reaction to a choice is to put it off. Finally, put the question last: a sign-off or a pleasantry after it pulls it away from the box where the reply gets typed.

What does not belong in a first message

The first message opens a conversation without trying to close it. Anything that asks the prospect for a commitment before they have replied even once works against you.

  • The calendar link: a Calendly in the first message asks for half an hour from someone who has not said a word to you yet. At Makelead the rule is simple, never a calendar link in the first message, talk first.
  • The price: given before the person has acknowledged the problem, it is compared to nothing and always looks too expensive.
  • The demo and the call: they cost time, and nobody gives their time to a stranger on the strength of three lines.
  • Links and attachments: a link to your website or a PDF brochure make the message look like a sales blast before the prospect even knows who you are.

All of this has its place later. When the prospect replies, you ask one or two questions about their situation, and a call comes naturally when they bring it up themselves or the conversation calls for it.

Overused phrases and the tone that sounds like AI

Some phrases appear in so many messages that they flag a template from the first words: “I hope this message finds you well”, “I'm reaching out because”, “feel free to”, “opportunity”, “synergy”. They carry no information, and each one pushes the sentence that matters a little further down.

The tone of generated text gives itself away the same way. Bullet lists, long dense paragraphs, the long dash in the middle of sentences and brochure vocabulary such as “innovative”, “boost” or “tailored” betray a message written by a tool or copied from a brochure. A prospect who gets several messages a week spots them instantly. Write the way you would talk to this person if you met them at an event, with short sentences, plain words and a concrete example in place of every adjective.

The invitation note and the follow-up follow other rules

The note attached to an invitation is limited to 200 characters, and a free account can add a note to only 3 invitations a month (Premium members, to all of them). Its only job is to get the connection accepted: one concrete reason to connect, with no offer and no link, and the question is optional. To write it with a counter that accounts for variables, use the LinkedIn invitation note tool.

The follow-up has to bring something new. “Just following up” only reminds the prospect that they have not replied. An article that speaks to their situation, an example from a client close to theirs or a precise result gives them a new reason to write back. It is the one moment in the sequence where a link belongs, as long as it leads to a useful resource and not to your pricing page. To chain the note, the first message and the follow-ups in the right order, start from the LinkedIn prospecting sequence.

An example, before and after

Here is the message the tool shows when it opens, a first message like the ones everybody receives:

Hi Thomas, I hope you're doing well. I'm reaching out because I help agencies like yours with their LinkedIn prospecting. We have helped several founders structure their follow-ups and save time every week. Is this a topic for you right now? How do you handle it today?

It scores 60 out of 100. It contains two overused phrases and two questions in a row, and nothing shows the sender knows who Thomas is. The corrected version drops the phrases, keeps the easier question and adds one sentence that can only be meant for him:

Hi Thomas, I saw you are opening a second agency in Denver. I help agencies like yours with their LinkedIn prospecting, especially when the sales team starts growing. Is that something on your plate right now?

Paste that second version into the analyzer and it scores 100. The message is no longer than the first one, it is simply turned toward Thomas from start to finish.

The right pace once the message is ready

A good message is wasted if it goes to too many people too fast. LinkedIn watches invitation volume, and an account that sends in bursts ends up restricted. Makelead caps sending at 200 invitations over any rolling 7 days, chains the note, the first message and the follow-ups you wrote once, and stops a prospect's sequence as soon as they reply. The conversation then continues between the two of you, with messages you will have checked here.

Frequently asked questions

How do I write a LinkedIn outreach message that gets a reply?

Start with the first name and one specific fact about the person, say in one sentence what you do for people like them, and end with a single question that takes one line to answer. Two to four lines are enough. No link, no price and no meeting request in the first message.

How is the score calculated?

Every message starts at 100. Each mistake removes points according to its weight: a calendar link in a first message removes 30, an overused phrase removes 4. The weight also depends on the message type, because a link is a mistake in an invitation note and can be the right move in a follow-up that shares an article.

Should I put a Calendly link in my first message?

No. A calendar link asks for time from someone who has not said a word to you yet. Talk first: when the prospect replies, ask one or two questions about their situation, and suggest a call when they bring it up or the conversation calls for it.

Is my message sent anywhere?

No. The analysis runs entirely in your browser, with fixed rules, no AI and no server. You can paste a message containing client names without any risk.

How many outreach messages should I send per day?

Volume matters less than the quality of each message, but it has a ceiling. Makelead sends at most 200 invitations over any rolling 7 days, and stops a prospect's sequence as soon as they reply, so the conversation carries on between the two of you.

Other free tools